Here are the comments people had about the candidates:

About Anthony Edwards: "He is not gay."

About Goran Visnjik: "He looks distinctly like another Latin gem...can we say...antionio banderas....!!!! He adds spice to the show. :) and he has a heart of gold. isn't that a nice, cheesy THANG?"

About Paul McCrane: "He is the kindest, most caring doctor on ER. And very handsome too." "He's the only doctor on the show with a sense of humor."

About George Clooney: "He's the only good one from ER. dude. um. maybe a pair of L.A. Gears. he's old, you see."

About Noah Wyle: "He's so cute. Even though he doesn't have a tongue ring."